I have been using Castor Oil grease (Black Thang Shea Butter and Castor Oil pomade), and various other greases like Blue Magic (original blue formula), Allways Super Lite Indian Hemp, etc...and it does work very well for keeping the moisture in my hair, esp. on the ends! Works wonders on DD's tightly coiled and dry 4a/b hair.
Grease does give a great shine, and I haven't seen such shine unless using serums or coconut oil. My hair definitely sucks up the lighter oils, but not the grease! I used to use Royal Crown (green and red tin), and Dax. I didn't realize Dax had such good ingredients behind the petroleum! Will be getting a jar next week!
Thanks Bublin for the great thread!
Sometimes I notice coconut oil makes my hair feel hard and dry if I apply it to damp hair and let it airdry. I've used other oils like avocado, grapeseed, and sesame instead, and they seem to do well. Or, I'll use those oils OVER the coconut oil to combat that hard feeling. I've used grease for many, many years and it has never failed me or had an adverse effect on my hair or scalp. No issues with slow growth due to this "clogging of the pores" people associate with grease. Not a problem here!
I find sealing my ends with grease after a wash keeps my ends and hair moisturized ALL WEEK without adding additional product. If it ain't broke, don't fix it!