I've used the Jamaican Island scalp cleanser and I like it. Leaves my hair feeling clean and moisturized. It isn't sudsy, so if you like suds, then don't get it. Other than that,
I also like the Jamaica Islands Scalp cleanser, it has a nice scent. I have also tried the Repear, Honeynut, and Honeybee scalp cleansers and I like them all!! I always repurchase the Jamaica Islands cleanser though.