Any recs for a fat black eyeliner pencil?

[PhonyBaloney500]

Can anyone recommend a fat black eyeliner pencil? My Benefit Bad Gal is finally dwindling to nothing after who knows how many eons. I want to try something else.

Disclaimer: There's no NYX as far as I've see in NY though I know they have some nice ones and I'd rather not order online...

[laCriolla]

stila kajal

goes on very easily, won't pull at your skin
but you should set it with a powder.

i love it, it's great for the waterline

http://www.sephora.com/browse/product.jhtml?id=P114407

[almondjoi85]

I'm a fan on Bobbi Brown Liner Gels, you can apply as much as you want to create a thick or thin look.

[BKVincy]

Mac fluidline blacktrack is a great liner

VS made a fat black pencil called smolder

MAC still makes a black Khol pencil called smolder

[LovelyLionessa]

Revlon makes a fat black liner. It's from their Beyond Natural line.

[cocoagirl]

Can anyone recommend a fat black eyeliner pencil? My Benefit Bad Gal is finally dwindling to nothing after who knows how many eons. I want to try something else.

Disclaimer: There's no NYX as far as I've see in NY though I know they have some nice ones and I'd rather not order online...

do you man NYX doesn't carry black eyeliner or you dont' know where to find NYX in nyc? b/c they do carry black and they also sell it at Beauty 35 on 8th and 35th, I havent' used black but I have used Iced Gold (may not be the name, iced something) and so far so good. they also sell nyx at the bss's at fulton mall, seen with my own eyes;-)